
(This post is the second main part of my response to David Allen. Part one can be found here.)
Responding to David Allen
Keep in mind that I am dealing with Norm’s notes rather than Allen’s own words, but I assume that Norm has presented a fair summary.
(Update: SBC Today has since begun a series on Dr. David Allen’s presentation at the John 3:16 conference.)
Norm says that Allen takes “spiritual ‘deadness’ [to be] metaphorical” and “Allen noted that spiritual death means primarily separation from God, not a total inability to respond to God.” Such a view of you were dead in the trespasses and sins in which you once walked significantly weakens Paul’s point. According to Allen, Paul is not saying we are corpses unable to move toward God; instead, we are simply in the wrong place but retain some mobility. Separation is a matter of geography. Allen makes this distinction between inability and separation because he, like many non-Calvinists, wishes to preserve some measure of fallen human ability. Fallen man retains the ability to respond to God. If we were to play a cosmic version of “Marco, Polo” with God, we retain the natural ability to seek out and follow the sound of his voice. Indeed, this is how many non-Calvinists see the process of salvation: we respond to the wooing and drawing of the Spirit by embracing God by faith. He gives the call, the offer, the woo, the summons; we respond by taking hold of him by faith; God then saves us. They are careful to affirm that the wooing of the Spirit is necessary, but so is the human response. The natural response from natural human ability is a necessary component in a non-Calvinist system of salvation.
Such a position stands in opposition to Paul’s point. In Ephesians 2:1-10, he does not attribute to man a single iota of movement toward God. When he speaks about man, the story is entirely negative. When he speaks about salvation, the work belongs entirely to God, even the faith with which we believe. Nothing comes from the humans being saved except for their sin.
Continue reading Spiritual Death: A Response to David Allen